next up previous
Next: The Stone-Cech Compactification Up: Applications of Weak Topologies Previous: Applications of Weak Topologies

Sobcyzk's Theorem

Motivation:
In a Banach space $ X$, $ M \leq X$ is complemented if there exists $ N \leq X$ such that $ N + M = X$, $ N \cap M = 0$.
We showed $ M$ is complemented iff there is a bounded projection $ P:X \rightarrow X$ such that % latex2html id marker 14334
$ \textrm{ran }P = M$.

Remark: $ c_0$ is not complemented in $ \ell^\infty$.

Theorem 3.1.1 (Sobcyzk, 1941)  
Let $ Y \leq X$, $ X$ a separable Banach space such that $ Y$ is isometrically isomorphic to $ c_0$. Then, there is a projection of $ X$ onto $ Y$ of norm at most $ 2$.

It suffices to prove that if $ T_0 \in B(Y,c_0)$ with $ \Vert T_0\Vert = \lambda$, then there exists $ T \in B(X,c_0)$ with $ \Vert T\Vert \leq 2 \lambda$ (apply this result with $ T_0$ the identity on $ Y$).

Proof. (Veech, PAMS, '71)
Let $ S = \overline{B_\lambda(0)}$ in $ X^*$ with the wk $ ^*$-topology. We know $ S$ is compact and metrizable. Let $ d$ be a metric giving this topology. Notice $ T_0(Y)$ are sequences.
For each $ n \in \mathbb{N}$, by Hahn-Banach, there is $ \phi_n \in X^*$ so that $ \phi_n(y)$ is the $ n^{th}$ element of $ T_0(y)$ for all $ y \in Y$.

Let $ K = S \cap Y^\perp$.

Claim: Every wk $ ^*$-cluster point of $ (\phi_n)$ is in $ K$.
If $ \phi_{n_k} \rightarrow \phi$ in wk $ ^*$, then

$\displaystyle \phi(y) = \lim_k \phi_{n_k}(y) = \lim_k (T_0(y))_{n_k} = 0 $

as $ T_0(y) \in c_0$. That is, dist $ (\phi_n,K) \rightarrow 0$ as $ n \rightarrow \infty$. Pick $ \psi_n \in K$ such that $ \Vert\phi_n - \psi_n\Vert =$   dist $ ( \phi_n,K )$ (as $ K$ is wk $ ^*$-compact and dist  is lower semicontinuous). Thus, $ )$ is the only wk $ ^*$-cluster point of $ (\phi_n - \psi_n)$ in $ \overline{B_{2\lambda}(0)}$ in $ X^*$.
Since this sequence has a wk $ ^*$-cluster point, we have

$\displaystyle (\phi_n - \psi_n) \rightarrow 0 $

in the wk $ ^*$-topology.
Define $ T:X \rightarrow c_0$ by

$\displaystyle (T(x))_n = \phi_n(x) - \psi_n(x). $

Clearly, $ T$ extends $ T_0$. ( $ \phi_n \subset Y^\perp$) and $ \Vert T\Vert \leq 2 \lambda$ ( $ \phi_n - \psi_n \in \overline{B_{2\lambda}(0)}$). Then $ T$ is the required projection if $ T_0$ is the identity map. $ \qedsymbol$


next up previous
Next: The Stone-Cech Compactification Up: Applications of Weak Topologies Previous: Applications of Weak Topologies
Brian Bockelman 2006-04-21